Harlequins v Saracens Prem Preview

Talisman

By Sarrov
October 18 2026

I have never liked the Champions Cup anyway, the league is what really matters!

All jokes aside, unlike “Europe” the Premiership represents a realistic chance of silverware this season. We have the squad to compete with anyone in the league, whether or not the same can be said for our coaching staff is definitely still up for debate.

 

On Sunday we head to The Stoop to take on Harlequins, a side that remains our keenest rival for my money. Quins have had a poor start to the season, losing all three of their league games so far and sitting rock bottom of the table. However, they looked a lot better against Sale last time out in the league and convincingly beat Vannes in their first Challenge Cup game.

 

A major factor in their improving form is the return of Marcus Smith. He seems to be developing a good understanding with new signing George Furbank which is allowing them to get the likes of Murley and Northmore into the game more. The game against Vannes was also the first run out of the season for wing Rodrigo Isgro. The Argentine is a player who can make something out of nothing with a combination of pace and power. 20 year old scrum half Lucas Friday is gaining experience at the top level week by week and looks a serious talent. Frankly, if we defend anything like we did against Connacht things could get slightly ugly.

 

Up front it is not such a pretty picture for the men from TW2. Their pack has come off second best in all three Prem games, with the likes of Cunningham-South punching well below their weight. Club captain Alex Dombrandt is likely to miss most (if not all) of the season due to an ACL injury. Their ranks will be bolstered however by the return of loosehead Fin Baxter.

 

As for our Saracens. I personally don’t think we have managed to put together an impressive 80 minutes so far this season. Leicester was an encouraging start and we comfortably beat a depleted Bristol, but the Sale and Connacht performances looked like a team who had never met each other before and with no plan B. The rotation policy seems to be inhibiting much cohesion between the players and they often look slightly lost in both attack and defence. There have been some bright signs in attack - most notably the set move for Elliott’s try against Leicester and the slick counter attack leading to Caluori crossing against Bristol. The scrum has also held its own or better in every game which hasn’t always been the case in the last few years. Alongside a generally solid line out we have a platform to play off, time for Dai Flanagan to earn his corn.

 

I know I speak for a lot of supporters when I say that Sunday is a massive fixture. Quins always raise their game against us and we often seem to turn up thinking we can cruise to victory. It is vital we bring accuracy and intensity from the first whistle, don’t give them a sniff. With that it mind, my side would be:

 

  1. Mawi              16. Clake

  2. George           17. Brantingham

  3. Street             18. Weilbach

  4. Itoje               19. Tizard

  5. Martin            20. Michelow

  6. JMG                21. C.Bracken

  7. Knight            22. Hall

  8. Earl                23. Caluori

  9. Williams

  10. Burke

  11. Segun

  12. Va’eneku

  13. Cinti

  14. J.Bracken

  15. Malins

 

*assuming injuries to Carre, Dan, Hadfield, Sodeke, Barbeary, Hartley, Elliott

 

Whoever takes the field, let’s hope that there is more cohesion and some proof that our desire to “dominate” and “flip the script” to get defence back on top are more than just empty words.

 

 

Bookmark or share this story with:

Harlequins v Saracens Prem Preview
Discussion started by TheSaracens.com , 18/10/2026 15:55
TheSaracens.com
18/10/2026 15:55
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

MarkCol7
18/10/2026 17:51
Michelow and Christie must be due starts

Quins with a confidence boosting 50 point win today aswell

TommyKentish
18/10/2026 18:42
Agree with you Sarrov, we haven’t really seen an impressive performance so far.

In terms of personnel it’s difficult to say because as ever the club have been fairly silent on injuries. Martin and JMG for example, no idea where they are right now, either way a rather frustrating set of injuries as a lot of our carrying power is in the treatment room. I’d like to see O’Driscoll on the bench, thought he had a really encouraging performance v Bristol, even if they were rotated. I’ll keep banging the drum for Hall at 13, especially if Burke is at 10 so he can pick up kicking duties (not that Faz is covering himself in glory in that department). The obviously problem then is we then pair Va’enuku with yet another 13.

It all rather pales in significance to the overarching issues though. Our defence simply hasn’t improved at all, even v Bristol there were times when they were a pass away from cutting us open on first phase and a dodgy pass from them helped us out. This could be down to rotation but honestly, defence has been leaky for a while now. If we are concentrating on our defence to the detriment of our attack then God help us because our attack is extremely clunky, our attacking breakdown work hasn’t improved in years seemingly and our attacking maul is good all over the pitch until we get within 10ms of the tryline. There are some personnel changes that might help but if Connacht can stick 7 tries on us then Smtih/Furbank will have some fun. Maybe it’ll be a reaction performance we’ve seen over the last few years every now and again but it’s seems unlikely when we come up against Quins in their annual final mode at the stoop.

Sarrov
18/10/2026 19:10
One thing on Hall - are we sure he is a fantastic kicker as opposed to just having a good game in preseason? Genuine question as I don't think I have ever seen him kick before.

Burke was fantastic off the tee against Leicester and then back to decidedly average against Sale.

I want him involved either way but curious to hear from others with more intel

PaulHerox
18/10/2026 19:35
Quote:
Sarrov
One thing on Hall - are we sure he is a fantastic kicker as opposed to just having a good game in preseason? Genuine question as I don't think I have ever seen him kick before

I'd love to know that too.
Tbh when I've seen him playing at 13 as opposed to wing I've not been super confident he is ready for the step up and I wouldn't "promote" him on the basis of kicking alone especially as 13 is a position we actually have options.

Quins were good today and Smith played very well but I'd hope we know enough not to give him the times and space Vannes did.

TommyKentish
18/10/2026 20:35
Quote:
Sarrov
One thing on Hall - are we sure he is a fantastic kicker as opposed to just having a good game in preseason? Genuine question as I don't think I have ever seen him kick before.
Burke was fantastic off the tee against Leicester and then back to decidedly average against Sale.

I want him involved either way but curious to hear from others with more intel

It’s a fair point, possibly me clutching at straws. I think 12 successful conversions is nothing to be sniffed at though, matter the quality of the oppoisition. I also think he’s an excellent talent either way and his future IMO is at 13 more than in the back 3. Re Burke’s kicking, we have far more data to suggest it won’t ever be massively reliable.

Sarrov
18/10/2026 20:51
Quote:
TommyKentish
Quote:
Sarrov
One thing on Hall - are we sure he is a fantastic kicker as opposed to just having a good game in preseason? Genuine question as I don't think I have ever seen him kick before.
Burke was fantastic off the tee against Leicester and then back to decidedly average against Sale.

I want him involved either way but curious to hear from others with more intel

It’s a fair point, possibly me clutching at straws. I think 12 successful conversions is nothing to be sniffed at though, matter the quality of the oppoisition. I also think he’s an excellent talent either way and his future IMO is at 13 more than in the back 3. Re Burke’s kicking, we have far more data to suggest it won’t ever be massively reliable.

No, definitely not to be sniffed at.

I also want to see him at 13. I was so frustrated against Bristol when we gave him less than 10 minutes and on the wing. I thought CInti and Va'eneku played well together against Bristol so would stick with them as a starting pair. Ditch the 6/2 and have Hall as an option off the bench.

I think a kicker can improve through hard work as it is a relatively closed skill. I don't think Burke will ever be Jonny Wilkinson kicking wise, but he could be Toby Flood!

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net